Skip to main content
AI True Crime
A Podcast untouched by human hands.
19 hours ago

The Long Island Serial Killer - Part 1

The Gilgo Beach killer and Police indifference

Chapters

  1. 0:00Chapter 1

AI True Crime: The Long Island Serial Killer

Episode One: The Bodies on Ocean Parkway

On May 1, 2010, twenty-three-year-old Shannan Gilbert made a desperate 911 call from Oak Beach, Long Island. She believed someone was trying to kill her. Within hours, she had vanished into the darkness.

Seven months later, a police officer and his dog discovered human remains beside Ocean Parkway. They did not belong to Shannan. Within days, investigators uncovered four murdered women concealed along the same remote stretch of coastal highway.

They became known as the Gilgo Four: Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello.

But the discoveries were only the beginning. Additional searches uncovered remains connected to murders dating back to the 1990s. Some victims had been dismembered, their remains scattered across Long Island. Others remained unidentified for decades.

As the investigation expanded, troubling questions emerged about Suffolk County law enforcement, missed opportunities, police corruption, and the treatment of missing women who worked in the sex industry.

For more than a decade, the investigation produced no arrest. Families continued demanding answers while evidence accumulated in police files. In 2022, a new task force began examining the case from the beginning. Within weeks, investigators discovered a connection that had been overlooked for years.

In the first episode of our two-part investigation, AI True Crime examines the disappearance that exposed a serial killer, the women whose bodies were discovered, and the extraordinary failures that allowed the murders to remain unsolved for so long.

Seven chapters:

  1. The Woman Who Called for Help
  2. Four Women in the Sand
  3. The Others
  4. Before Gilgo
  5. The Woman They Were Looking For
  6. A Killer Protected by Silence
  7. Twelve Years of Nothing

Content advisory: This episode discusses serial murder, violence against women, dismemberment, sex work, and police misconduct.

Research and Sources

Suffolk County District Attorney, People v. Rex Heuermann, official investigation and case records

https://www.suffolkcountyda.org/gilgo/

Associated Press, timeline of the Gilgo Beach investigation

https://apnews.com/article/c6ea9b229f3d9d15ba30b5d4a03af29b

ABC News, comprehensive timeline of the murders and investigation

https://abcnews.com/US/gilgo-beach-murders-timeline-investigation/story?id=101428812

CBS News / 48 Hours, Long Island serial killings investigation timeline

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/long-island-serial-killings-investigation-timeline-48-hours/

ABC News, biographical reporting on the eight identified victims of Rex Heuermann

https://abcnews.com/US/alleged-victims-gilgo-beach-suspect-rex-heuermann/story?id=131798753

WSHU Public Radio, release of Shannan Gilbert's 911 recording

https://www.wshu.org/long-island-news/2022-05-13/suffolk-police-release-911-call-in-gilgo-beach-homicide-investigation

ABC News, Shannan Gilbert's 911 calls and the police investigation

https://abcnews.com/US/911-calls-released-connection-woman-disappearance-led-gilgo/story?id=84644473

Michael Baden, independent forensic report concerning Shannan Gilbert

https://crimetimelines.com/wp-content/uploads/Gilbert-Baden-Autopsy-Report-2-11-16.pdf

ABC News, identification of Karen Vergata

https://abcnews.com/US/authorities-identify-victim-gilgo-beach-investigation/story?id=102013504

Associated Press, identification of Tanya Jackson and Tatiana Dykes

https://apnews.com/article/fbc0bb3f6c6922a898cfbadc25ccc00d

U.S. Department of Justice, convictions of Thomas Spota and Christopher McPartland in the James Burke corruption case

https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/former-suffolk-county-district-attorney-thomas-j-spota-and-government-corruption-bureau

U.S. Department of Justice, sentencing of Spota and McPartland

https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/former-suffolk-county-district-attorney-thomas-j-spota-and-government-corruption-bure-0

Newsday, the Chevrolet Avalanche lead and the investigation that identified Rex Heuermann

https://newsday.atexcloud.io/long-island/crime/how-the-gilgo-task-force-got-rex-heuermann-a-chevrolet-avalanche-pizza-crust-and-burner-cellphones-ytyq263l

Newsday, November 2026 developments in the separate Tanya Jackson murder prosecution

https://newsday.atexcloud.io/long-island/crime/gilgo-beach-killings/peaches-tanya-jackson-gilgo-beach-victim-no-3-andrew-dykes-rgs46m9n

Important Case Distinctions

Shannan Gilbert's cause and manner of death remain officially undetermined. Investigators have not established that her death was caused by the murderer responsible for the Gilgo Four.

Tanya Denise Jackson and her daughter, Tatiana Marie Dykes, were identified in 2025. In a separate prosecution, Andrew Dykes has been charged with Tanya Jackson's murder and has pleaded not guilty. As of November 2026, he has not been charged with Tatiana's death.

The criminal convictions involving former Suffolk County Police Chief James Burke and former District Attorney Thomas Spota concerned a separate assault and obstruction investigation. They do not establish that either man participated in or knowingly concealed the Gilgo Beach murders.

Coming in Episode Two: The Architect

A suburban family home. A Manhattan architecture firm. Disposable cellphones, genetic evidence, and an abandoned pizza crust.

After twelve years without an arrest, investigators finally have a name. In Part Two, we follow the evidence that exposed the killer and brought one of America's most disturbing serial murder investigations to its conclusion.

AI True Crime. The intelligence is artificial, but the crime is real.

This podcast is powered by Pinecast.